The Shocking Truth: Why a Sustainable T-Shirt Can Cost $36

Mar 10, 2023Fashion7 comments

A couple of weeks ago, I posted on social media about the price of sustainable fashion. The point of the post was to show there are many ways to have a sustainable closet – you don’t have to buy anything new. But if you do buy a new article of clothing from a sustainable brand, it can’t be done cheaply. There are fair costs that go into making a garment and labeling it ‘sustainable/ethical.’ I quickly learned from many comments that there is a complete disconnect between manufacturing and customers. We’ve been so used to seeing a $5-10 t-shirt we can’t fathom why it would cost over $30? This sparked my interest in creating a new line of posts on Sustainably Chic. I’m calling it the True Cost Series, and on the 1st of each month, I will take a garment from a sustainable brand & break down the cost.

Note: Since creating this post, the cost of manufacturing has increased. The shirt that once was $36 is now $44. The photos in this post reflect the old cost of production.

Why is Sustainable Fashion More Expensive?

Sustainable fashion often comes with a higher price tag, and that’s because it actually reflects the real cost of making clothing the right way. From the certified organic cotton that costs more to grow, to paying garment workers a living wage in safe working conditions, every step of the process is done more ethically and transparently. Unlike fast fashion brands that can cut corners with mass production, cheap synthetic materials, and unfair labor, sustainable brands prioritize people and the planet, which means smaller batches, higher-quality materials, and ethical factory partners. It’s not about inflating prices, it’s about covering the true cost of thoughtful production.

Check out our other True Cost Series:

The High Price Of Hemp & Cost Breakdown Of A Towel

Cost Per Wears With A Classic Denim Jacket

A Bra With No Secrets

The Garment

Fair Trade Unisex Tee

$36, Ethically Made in India

The perfect starting point is our beloved plain jersey cotton t-shirt! It’s the most basic part of a wardrobe and will likely be the smallest price point in this series.

I want to thank The Good Tee for being my guinea pig and making such a fantastic, thoughtful t-shirt! I’m wearing the Slim Fit Short Sleeve in the first photo, which is the same price as this one.

The Cost of Manufacturing

The first thing that comes to mind is ‘sewing,’ which is just one of 10 manufacturing price breakdowns for this t-shirt. Since The Good Tee uses Fair Trade Certified Organic Cotton, the material price is already higher. They are also a smaller brand, ordering smaller volumes so that it won’t have significant volume price breaks. If you are unfamiliar, conventional cotton uses several harmful toxic chemicals (such as dangerous insecticides like aldicarb, parathion, and methamidophos) to grow, which aren’t only damaging our soil, but the communities growing the crops. Using a strictly regulated clean fiber ensures the safety and well-being of farmers, our health, and the planet. Fairtrade cotton also protects farmers; since 1997, nearly 200k farmers in India have committed suicide.

India is an excellent location for manufacturing cotton products because they have some of the best organic cotton fields and certified factories to produce fabric and clothing. While it only accounts for about 1% of their farms, it still produces the most organic cotton compared to any other country. To read more about Indian cotton farmers and their path to organic, visit this link.

I love this cost breakdown from The Good Tee. It lays it all out there so you can see just how much goes into manufacturing a garment. From the fiber to the trimming from the production to the duties (18%!!!), every brand should offer their consumers a way to see what goes into the clothing you wear every day.

Now, after you see it takes almost $10 to make a fair trade t-shirt, HOW can brands like H&M create t-shirts (with partly organic materials) for half the price – without even adding the rest of the business expenses on in the markup?! And, yet, H&M is worth a whopping 18 BILLION dollars! It’s all done at the cost of people & the environment – and we can say this for most fashion retailers today.

Local Business Costs

So, what about the other $26? The associated costs of doing business are another disconnect many consumers have. When you spend so much time creating a brand, it would be nice to profit the full $26, but not even close. You still have overhead to pay for (which would be your warehouse or storefront), and if you are also a wholesaler, you would have additional cuts to provide for other retailers. Your employees – and the owner – must be paid. The Good Tee manufactures offshore but still employs domestically. Most of the product development is done locally, and they have a graphic designer, technical designer, pattern maker, and sample maker to create every style. Then you have marketing, which is an essential part of a business and should account for 8% of your gross revenue. After all is said and done, you want to reinvest in the business and new product, which takes money, too.

WHEW! That’s a lot, isn’t it?! I hope this series continues bridging the gap between manufacturing and consumers so that we find more respect in the work that goes into the clothing we love to wear every day. Next time you see a garment and think the price is outrageous, send the brand an email and see if they can explain their price breakdown. Transparency is so important today.

*this is just an example and is not a universal price for every sustainably-made product – costs will vary from brand to brand*

~ related reading you may enjoy ~

Subscribe
Notify of
7 Comments
Oldest
Newest
6 years ago

Great post, thank you for sharing this.

It’s time for us to all realise the true costs involved in our purchases so we can make eco choices with confidence, bravo xx

Nurul Amin
5 years ago

What percentage of the customer is now ready to pay this cost for a plain tee? And what percentage of brands really want sourcing sustainably at this way & at this price? Hope willing buyers who are continuously marketing by telling their customers as sustainable sourced product will raise their hands!!!

Natalie Kay
5 years ago
Reply to  Nurul Amin

Well, it’s obviously somewhat low, that is why I created this series. More & more brands DO want to pay people fairly, and, luckily, more customers are willing to do the same.

Amanda
5 years ago

Thank you for sharing this information. Good post.
https://www.tshirtideal.ca/t-shirts/long-sleeves.html

LoudPen
5 years ago

This post was absolutely amazing!!! I’m doing research for a business course I am taking and stumbled across this article. I just launched my own line of Organic Cotton T-Shirts and I get this consumer kickback all of the time. It irritates me because people are so thirsty for high fashion brands like Gucci and Prada who sell T-Shirts for like $150 but these same people turn their noses up at $36 organic/sustainable T-shirt. And as far as the $10-15 tees – those aren’t even worth that low price. Conventional cotton tees feel awful in comparison to organic cotton, you couldn’t pay me to wear regular cotton since I launched my brand. Lol sorry not sorry. So anyway, these days I just brush off the people who don’t see my vision and don’t want to spend that much on a T-shirt. I just chalk it up to them not being my target audience

Steve H
4 years ago

Fantastic post – this ‘complete disconnect with manufacturing and customers’ is something we really need to work on, along with the approach of customers buying better quality garments in lower quantities

Bxtribe
3 years ago

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!
https://www.bxtribe.com/collections/men